Translated automatically. Show original
It says 3 and 5, but she wrote down 2 and 4. The teacher already marked everything in red. The teacher is just freaking out, giving a failing grade. She's annoyed that she makes a mistake with the numbering every time. And what about Drittel? It's already 3rd grade, and she's been studying since she was 6.5 years old.
Comments
Sign In
Kupava
Because it might be uncomfortable, maybe your fingers are short and the keys are far apart.
I used to mix them up when I played too, but nobody really paid attention to it.
Translated automatically. Show original
Antonina
It's either a hand peculiarity or the way the hand is positioned is just awkward. I had the second situation as a child and struggled with it for a long time.
Translated automatically. Show original
Anna
Buy valerian for the teacher
Translated automatically. Show original
Gulya
That kind of teacher just kills your motivation.
I'd think about finding a new one.
Translated automatically. Show original
Tatyana
Maybe she doesn't want to delve into it, doesn't want to figure out the notes on her own, and is distracted during practice. It's hard for kids to focus and do what they're assigned these days, hard to be responsible and interested because there are so many distractions (shops, TV, smartphones, games)… that's why she mixes up her fingers. During music class, it's impossible for the teacher to sit and go over the fingerings again and again. The child has to do this themselves at home, as it's a pre-professional program, not just a hobby club.
Translated automatically. Show original
Kristina
The teacher should put their hand on
Translated automatically. Show original
Anna Morozova
Tatyana 1. She was given a summer program. She figured it out on her own.
2. By the 3rd lesson, she had to play from memory. Since she always figures things out herself, not with a teacher, she memorizes the wrong fingerings.
3. During lessons, material is just given out, mistakes are corrected, and you get a 2 for mistakes. Mistakes are wrong fingerings.
4. She doesn't play on her smartphone and never has. She does sports 5 times a week for 2 hours, is homeschooled, gets enough sleep, and sleeps until 9-10 AM. She goes to bed at 11 PM. She doesn't watch TV all day. A little in the evening.
5. Her attention has always been scattered. Since birth.
Translated automatically. Show original
Anna Morozova
Kristina In 2.5 years, she's had:
1. A teacher for music school prep + a tutor.
2. A teacher in the 1st grade of music school (she left after a year).
3. A teacher in the 2nd grade. But they changed him after 3 months themselves.
And now there's this teacher, who's nervous. Everything has to be perfect. But for her, it's never perfect. Even though she plays 4th-grade pieces. The teacher tells her: "Disgusting." She mixes up her fingers because of it. Every time, notes in the diary: wrong fingers
Translated automatically. Show original
Tatyana
Tatyana Got it, so you need to sit with her and supervise. Finger placement is the most important part of learning, it's the foundation. You have to sit with her and supervise. Start with the right hand part, have her play and intone the notes while naming the fingers instead of the notes. This way, she'll concentrate her attention. Otherwise, if she doesn't overcome herself and her distractibility, she won't be able to learn properly
Translated automatically. Show original
Mariya
She's not very interested and doesn't think it's important.
Mine also plays however she wants. Sometimes the teacher manages to correct her, and sometimes she doesn't.
But your teacher sounds like a mess, though.
Translated automatically. Show original
Guzel Hasanova
Because gladiolus. Heavy load makes my brain shut down. And the teacher just adds fuel to the fire
Translated automatically. Show original
Viktoriya
Tatyana There's an issue with point 2!
The teacher should have written down the fingerings right away if there was a problem. And it's harder to retrain fingers than to learn the correct ones from the start. Sometimes it's easier to just take a new piece and learn it than to retrain fingers, it'll be faster.
The teacher is weird! The child's fingers should be guided from the beginning, not get upset that the child is playing with the wrong fingers on their own.
Translated automatically. Show original

Read also

I posted earlier about almost fainting. It's been over two ho...
I found out (they didn't tell me right away, otherwise I would have fig...
Девочки, привет, подскажите пожалуйста какое слабительное м...